Vivian Folkenflik
Core Course | Translation |
In the news | Manifesto | Home
THINKING-MAKING-DOING
Syllabus, teaching tools, resources for students

The Artist in the Character of Design, listening to the inspiration of Poetry, by Angelica Kauffmann (1782), Kenwood Iveagh Bequest London (Yorck Project)

Shakespeare (Chandos portrait)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Thiking Making Doing

MAKING 2010 - Honors HCC 1B 29082

Monday-Wednesday 2-3:20 in HH 142. Some Wednesday classes may be held upstairs in the computer lab inside HH 269. Notice will be given!

E-Mail Listserve for Class: 29082-W10@classes.uci.edu

Vivian Folkenflik

Email vrfolken@uci.edu

Office Hours: Tuesday 12-2, Wednesday 12-1 in HIB 197 (in Core Course office; student entry door near Artsbridge)

HCC Winter syllabus https://eee.uci.edu/programs/humcore/Student/Winter2010/index.html


Message board:  Linked to your eee site https://eee.uci.edu/

 

Week One: https://eee.uci.edu/programs/humcore/Student/Winter2010/index.html

Shakespeare's Globe Theatre, London

Monday, January 6

 

Week One

Monday, January 4:  First Day of Class: Making Introductions

  • Reading: A Midsummer Night's Dream (Act I and Act II)
  • Our class: Janice, Ivana, Alex, Jaydee, Jeff, Jason, Chris, Nghiem, Jenny, Athena, Mike, Hannah, Mika, Allison, Jay, Michael, Madison

 

LN Wk1-1: A Midsummer Night's Dream Lecture 1

Reading: A Midsummer Night's Dream (Acts I-II, III if possible)

Three ways to consider "making" for Midsummer Night's Dream?

Craft: the skills of the "rude mechanicals"? the “made” or crafted character of Shakespeare’s drama as a collaborative art form? Drama: a form of making that involves the spoken word along with the use of movement, gesture, space, costume, lighting.

Imagination: the “made” or fictional character of the world Shakespeare represents?

Self-fashioning: the ways we all “make” our own lives, partly in response to the images and traditions, stories, scrips, rituals that surround us...?

 

Rhetoric: crafting a speech or text designed to persuade particular audiences in law courts, deliberative community groups, occasions of praise or blame...

 

Aristotle: persuasive arguments (good and bad) appeal to ethos, logos, and pathos; his analysis can be applied to other forms of speech and writing.

Ethos refers to the character, credibility, or authority of the speaker. An older speaker, for example, might use ethos when he or she refers to his or her position in society, past experience, skills and credentials, established traditions, authoritative texts, reputation... A younger speaker, on the other hand, might draw on other rhetorical resources of ethos such as his or her knowledge of new cultural developments, sense of responsibility for the future or for other people, good behavior in the past... which words signal ethos?

Pathos refers to the emotional impact of the speech both on characters on (0r off) stage and on the audience or reader: pity, fear, affection, family love, erotic desire, laughter, shame, anxiety... which words prompt pathos?

Logos refers to the logical structure of the argument or speech. In a speech delivered in a play, pay attention to understanding the speaker's main points, his or her use of evidence, syllogisms, analogies, examples, definitions, transitions, possible logical fallacies, causal assertions, evaluative claims, counterarguments, and other aspects of philosophical discourse. Investigating "Logos" often means exploring etymology and connotations of an interesting word. Try the OED. Which"Logos" words seem most important to you?

 

Wednesday, January 6 LN Wk 1-2: A Midsummer Night's Dream Lecture 2

  • Reading: A Midsummer Night's Dream (Acts III, IV, and V), Writer's Handbook "Genre" (Chapter 11) and "The Active Reading Process and Textual Explication" (Chapter 13)
  • Writing: Print out Essay Assignment #3 and Pre-Writing Grid for Essay Three
  • Bring "Making 'True Love' Happen"handout for groupwork
  • NOTE: My Handbook chapter 13 on Active Reading uses Theseus's speech (V, 1)! Bring your Handbook and questions to class. How -- and how successfully -- does Theseus try to convince his bride Hippolyta -- what's happened overnight in the Midsummer Night's Dream?

Diagnostic: On Hermia and Lysander's"She said, he said..." responses to tales and histories of love. Do you consider their responses gendered as "feminine"/"masculine" like the exchange of Anne Elliot and Captain Harville in Persuasion? How or why -- or why not?

Online Information Literacy Quiz assigned, due next Monday (linked to your eee).

Come prepared to think about why Shakespeare talks so much about "eyes": pp. 58-59, 132-33, 142, 191, 223, 248, 97-99, 128. What do we see? What don't we see? Who sees what?

"Research fun" suggested by Prof. Lupton on your Study Questions: 

1)      Search for a key word from A Midsummer Night’s Dream  in the on-line works of Shakespeare, http://www.it.usyd.edu.au/~matty/Shakespeare/test.html

2)      How many times does he use the word throughout his writing career? In which play or plays does this word occur most often?

3)      Look up the word in the OED. What meanings did it carry in Shakespeare’s day? How, if at all, have its meanings changed?

 Which keywords strike you as most interesting, whether in terms of ethos-logos-pathos... or making art? Possible words: fancy, fantasy, feign, imagination, toy, dream, conceit, consent, interlude, history, fairy, bottom, joiner, tinker, interlude, ass, preposterous, translate, transport

OXFORD ENGLISH DICTIONARY
http://dictionary.oed.com/

 

Three mini-plots: Romance plot, fairy plot, play-within-a play plot

In the romance plot, Shakespeare explores the power of love, in league with the imagination, to make, unmake, and remake relationships.

In the fairy plot, Shakespeare taps the ability of holiday and festival to make connections between the ordinary and the extraordinary.

In the scenes involving the play-within-a-play, Shakespeare both compares and contrasts his own theatrical making with the arts and crafts of the working men of Athens, whose skills have helped build the space of the theatre and the space of the city.

Three traditions: Shakespeare weaves together, like his character Bottom the weaver...?

  • the art of rhetoric,
  • holiday and festival,
  • popular romance, songs, stories...

 

 

 

 

 

 

Some websites you may find interesting:

Thomas Bulfinch's The Age of Fable is old-fashioned, but still useful for myths and tales of Theseus and others (1913, revised ed. online). Scroll down for Theseus, Pyramus and Thisbe, etc. on the "Gods and Heroes" page: http://www.bartleby.com/181/

 

A Midsummer Night's Dream ( DVD) © 20th Century Fox / Fox Searchlight - Optional: entire movie may be seen on Youtube, Blockbuster, Netflix; required clips will be shown in lecture and linked to homepage HCC syllabus

Iconographic and staging history of MSND: artists' images

http://www.english.emory.edu/classes/Shakespeare_Illustrated/MidsummerPaintings.html

 

 

Peter Quince Carpenter = builder (structure) Quince = "quines," blocks of wood used for building Director + Prologue
Nick Bottom Weaver = maker of cloth Bottom = skein on which yarn is wound, also bottom as in "butt" or "ass" Pyramus, the tragic lover
Francis Flute Bellows mender = repairs bellows used to increase flow of air to a fire or church organ Flute = high pitched voice of a boy actor or singer before his voice changes Thisbe, the female lead
Snug Joiner = skilled carpenter, makes furniture, cabinets Snug = close fitting, well-put together, joins traditions?

Lion

 

Robin Starveling Tailor = sews clothes, costumes Starveling = tailors were proverbially thin

Moonshine

 

Tom Snout Tinker = fixes things made of metal, mends pots and pans, Snout = spout of a kettle Wall

 

1] For Monday: Choose either Helena's speech (3.2.192-222, pp. 47-48) or Theseus's speech (5.1.1-27, pp. 70-71). Email me a paragraph about your choice, and some interesting ways you might use keywords for rhetorical analysis of the speeches (and the responses of Hermia and Hippolyta!). And remember to use your OED Oxford English Dictionary on your keywords! Bring in your pre-writing grid with some of these keywords filled out.

2] Click on your Honors Reading List: Read one or two of the following scholarly articles to enrich your own rhetorical analysis of Helena's or Theseus's speech. I like the Marshall article (#2), because David Marshall is an excellent reader of Shakespeare; and if you are choosing Theseus, Prof. Lupton also recommends the Montrose article (#6) as a way of considering the relationship between Theseus and Hippolyta.

From Prof. Julia Lupton:

James E. Robinson. The Ritual and Rhetoric of "A Midsummer Night's Dream." PMLA, Vol. 83, No. 2 (May, 1968), pp. 380-391. Modern Language Association.
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/1261192

David Marshall. Exchanging Visions: Reading A Midsummer Night's Dream. ELH, Vol. 49, No. 3 (Autumn, 1982), pp. 543-575. The Johns Hopkins University Press
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/2872755

Anca Vlasopolos. The Ritual of Midsummer: A Pattern for A Midsummer Night's Dream. Renaissance Quarterly, Vol. 31, No. 1 (Spring, 1978), pp. 21-29. The University of Chicago Press on behalf of the Renaissance Society of America
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/2860326

Mary Ellen Lamb. Taken by the Fairies: Fairy Practices and the Production of Popular Culture in A Midsummer Night's Dream. Shakespeare Quarterly, Vol. 51, No. 3 (Autumn, 2000), pp. 277-312. Folger Shakespeare Library in association with George Washington University.
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/2902152

C. L. Barber. The Saturnalian Pattern in Shakespeare's Comedy. The Sewanee Review, Vol. 59, No. 4 (Autumn, 1951), pp. 593-611. The Johns Hopkins University Press
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/27538096

 

"Shaping Fantasies": Figurations of Gender and Power in Elizabethan Culture by Louis Adrian Montrose. Representations, No. 2 (Spring, 1983), pp. 61-94. University of California Press Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/2928384

DVD screening? Ivana and Madison have borrowed my DVD of the Hoffman movie of Midsummer Night's Dream. Some of the speeches are cut, as we saw today in class, but it's beautifully acted and it helps students understand and interpret the plot. Contact Ivana and Madison through our class listserve 29082-W10@classes.uci.edu to find out when they are screening the film! Or consider getting it on Netflix or Youtube. Some students like to turn on the captions to follow along...

Monday, January 11:

Prof. Julia Lupton led our class in analyzing speeches from MSND, using speeches by Helena, Theseus, and Bottom. She began by reminding us that we were being asked to analyze a particular speech, using evidence from the speech to support our claims. (This is called a claim-evidence-warrant structure!) She wanted to see students read aloud, to get the dramatic sense of the speeches. And she ended by telling us that she believes we live our lives "with" the literary and artistic works we think about and process.

LOGOS: Prof. Lupton encouraged us to look for "clusters" of keywords that could help us understand Logos arguments (legal terms, for example, or extended metaphors that the Elizabethans called "conceits").

PATHOS: Prof. Lupton also encouraged us to look for different "layers" of Pathos, evidence of shifts or mixed feelings... even what she called "disavowal" of feelings! She used Photoshop as an example of how our vision changes when we choose a different layer...

ETHOS: And Prof. Lupton also discussed with us the Ethos of the characters: Bottom as someone who develops from someone who can't express what he's seen, to someone considering writing (or asking Peter Quince to write with him!) about his experiences; how we might think of Theseus's authority, and how Helena speaks from her experiences as an adolescent.

Thank you, Prof. Lupton!

 

Week Two Wednesday, January 13: Class in lab HH 269.

Your Ideas Draft: 2 pages. Due in Dropbox Friday 5 pm.

Tips: What are you being asked to do in this essay?

Remember your Persuasion essay? There, you were given a passage and an interpretive theme: how a change of place does (or doesn't) contribute to a change in the way a person thinks! In doing that, you also thought: how does this part of the story relate to the whole?

In #3, you are being given a passage, and building off that #2 experience. but you're asked to do some more developed work analyzing its rhetoric, and you're being asked to decide yourself the meaning or theme you find most important in your understanding of Shakespeare's play. The argument you make about that meaning or theme will be your thesis.

If you find that the play offers a mixed message, you may want to construct a yes/but or not only x but y thesis. See your Handbook to review this material!

Body paragraphs: Claim-evidence-warrant work counts to support the topic sentence claim of each paragraph.

Use of a secondary source: To develop your research skills: Try to include at least one reference to a claim by either Marshall or Montrose.

 

 

https://eee.uci.edu/programs/humcore/Student/Winter2010/index.html

  • Reading: Alberti, "On Painting" (Prologue, pp. 39-40; Book Two, pp. 63-85) For diagrams, click here
  • Writer's Handbook "Recognizing Rhetorical Context" (Chapter 14)
  • Raphael: "The Entombment"
  • And remember Raphael's School of Athens?
  • Writing: Ideas Draft for Essay Three will be due in eee dropbox Friday, January 15. 2 typed pages. I will respond to these Ideas Drafts over the long weekend (we have no class Monday) and you will turn in a Working Draft by the end of Week Three.
  • Artist Filippo Lippi with two of his pupils, from his series of paintings in an Italian cathedral on the "Life of the Virgin" http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Scenes_of_the_Life_of_the_Virgin

  • Reading: Alberti, "On Painting" (Book Two, pp. 63-85)
  • Logos, organization and istoria according to Alberti
  • Ethos and character of person[s] represented in painting
  • Pathos and viewer response to Renaissance painting
  • Commentator figure: look for it !
  • Compare and contrast medieval painting by Gaddi and Renaissance painting by Filippo Lippi
  • Compare and contrast figures of Adam and God in a painting by Michelangelo
  • Role of humanist artist according to Alberti (compared to members of crafts guilds, Rude Mechanicals... How important is it that the RMs can perform a play, with some success, in MSND? Are they participating in an art form? Maybe, maybe not... )
  • Importance of community of friends as Alberti's immediate audience ( 39-40)
  • Importance of community audience for painting - not just the educated, but also the "uneducated" (66-67)
  • Women as well as men can learn : everybody wants to try (except that in ancient Greece, slaves were not allowed to learn because it was considered such an honor (66).
  • Importance of art - "Painting contains a divine force which not only makes absent men present, as friendship is said to do, but moreover makes the dead seem almost alive" (63) .
  • The mirror: a good judge (?)
  • The pleasure of art: painting in particular...

Botticelli: self-portrait from Adoration

(Holiday Monday -- but be sure to attend Prof. Lupton's forum Friday 1/22! Honors forum is at 11:00, but there will also be one at 9:00.)

Wednesday, January 20

  • Reading: Alberti, "On Painting" (Book Three, pp. 89-98), Alberti, "On Painting" (Book Three, pp. 89-98)
  • Writer's Handbook "Analyzing Images " (Chapter 16)
  • Writing: Working Draft for Essay Three

 

Week Four

Monday, January25

  • Reading: HCC Course Reader, pp. 9-28 : “Germany:  Germany from 1918 to 1945,” “Proletarians!  Men and women of Labor!  Comrades!” “En Avant Dada:  A History of Dadaism,” “November Group Circular,” “November Group Manifesto,” “Work Council for Art Manifesto”
  • Writing: Peer Editing Comments for Essay Three

ESSAY 5: ANALYZING VISUAL IMAGES FOR AN ENCYCLOPEDIA ARTICLE. For this, we'll need to learn about the way a historian analyzes primary sources -- BOTH texts and images. The text you're using is in the Course Reader, and you're familiar with the Encyclopedia Britannica Online http://search.eb.com/

Note: Prof. Moeller's site asks you to do login and password 
http://www.humanities.uci.edu/~rmoeller/HCC_Lectures/RGM_Lecture1.html

http://www.humanities.uci.edu/~rmoeller/HCC_Cover/HCC_Bag.html

Password-protected Image Bank: http://www.humanities.uci.edu/~rmoeller/HCC_Cover/HCC_Image_Bank.html

What have we learned about 1916-1917 as a context for art in the early 20thc?

 

http://www.humanities.uci.edu/~rmoeller/HCC_Lectures/wwi_gallery.html

Wednesday, Jan 27

Groups

  • for Monday Germany 1918-1933
  1. Spartacist: Jaydee, Mika, Janice, Allison
  2. Dadaist: Mike N., Chris, Jenny, Evana
  3. Nazis: Michael W., Daniel, Jason, Jeff
  4. Photomontage/Heartfield: Nghiem, Jay, Athena
  5. Expressionist: Madison, Alex, Hannah

Groups today: 1: Spartacist Manifesto, 2] En Avant Dada, 3] November + Work Council for Art, 4] Art Scab, 5] Art is a Weapon!

 

  • Peter Paul Rubens, Bathsheba at the Fountain

What might Alberti say about it? What would the Art Scab writers like or not like? What's the istoria, anyway? Look up Bathsheba! Wiki? Britannica?

 

  • Georg Grosz is a co-author (with John Heartfield) of "The Art Scab;" here he is in his studio after the war (1920s, date uncertain). What can you tell from the photo of Georg Grosz below about the painting Grosz is doing at this time?

  • Works by John Heartfield, co-author of the Art Scab: from Bag of tricks and From Artstor

 

John Heartfield:Heartfield Image Gallery on Moeller's Bag of Tricks (from his website)...

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

RESEARCH RESOURCES for finding out about THE 6Cs From PROF. MOELLER: for HCC, the links below are a good place to start. You can connect directly to the links on campus. From off-campus, you will need to download the VPN software. Click here for instructions on how to connect from off-campus.

  • ANTPAC (the UCI library; try doing a subject search and see what happens)
  • MELVYL (a database that gets you to all the libraries of the UC system; when you find books you need that aren't in our library but are on another campus, you can request them and they will come to you in Irvine)
  • Oxford English Dictionary (fabulous resource provides not only definitions but a history of the usage of the word)
  • Britannica Online (high quality articles written by leading scholars in the field; a great place to start; articles also provide some bibliography and guides to further reading)
  • Grove Music Online (This extrarodinary resource provides information on individual composers, music genres, and the history of music. Articles also provide bibliography. You can get access on campus; or with a free download VPN software, you can log on from off-campus.)
  • Grove Art Online (Same Grove; this resource focuses on the arts...)
  • New York Times, 1857-1999 (full-text searchable, you can find articles and you can also see where the article appeared on the page; try a little "juxtaposition history" and see what events surround that event that interests you!)
  • JSTOR (a very extensive collection of on-line journals; the most recent editions of journals will not be listed here, and from 1-5 years of a journal may not yet be archived here; still, a very good place to start and anything you find, you can easily download.)
  • Historical Abstracts (where historians start to do literature searches for journal articles; many articles will be linked directly to UCI holdings, so if you find an article, you can often download it easily!)
  • Project Muse (another collection of on-line journals, doesn't overlap completely with JSTOR, so you should check both; anything you find can be downloaded!)
  • MLA International Bibliography (this is the counterpart to Historical Abstracts for people who work mainly in literarature; however, for something like Gershwin's Porgy and Bess, I would definitely look here too.)
  • WorldCat/First Search (An absolutely amaizng source. This will take you to articles, books, video sources, even archival sources; sometimes, you can get directly to the source, but when you can't, there's an easy function to send yourselves the references you discover!)
  • Library Subject Guides (and don't forget to look at the expert subject guides that the academic subject librarians have put together; academic subject librarians are highly trained scholars who have deep knowledge of many research fields. Take advantage of what they know!)

Week Five

Monday, February 1

  • Reading: HCC Course Reader, Review pp. 32-35: “Program of the Staatliches Bauhaus in Weimar"
  • Group presentations of art: Spartacist, Expressionists, Dadaist, Nazi, Photomontage/Heartfield.
  • Midterm Format and Questions: See Class listserv.
  • Politics and Art: Can a Maker not be a Doer?
  • Looking Ahead to #4: Honors Alternative for Weimar Paper -

    Students should follow the general prompt, but choose a theme to organize selection of images. Professor Moeller has provided additional reading resources for students, keyed to each theme. (For Art and Politics: Oxford Art On Line and the resources on Professor Moeller’s Web Resource page, http://www.humanities.uci.edu/~rmoeller/HCC_Cover/HCC_WebGuide.html .) You may also want to direct students to additional databases, such as the US Holocaust Museum (http://www.ushmm.org/  ) or Calvin College’s Nazi and East German Propaganda page (http://www.calvin.edu/academic/cas/gpa/ ) .

    Students should use ARTstor with dates 1918-1933 to make sure that they are choosing images within the prompt guidelines. Be sure that images you choose from the Calvin site (if you find some there) also fit into this time frame.

     Possible themes (check the drop-down Honors

     

    menu on HCC home page)

    1. Representations of gender and sexuality
    2. Memories of the First World War

ARTSTOR DISCOVERY TASK DUE MONDAY! Formatted version in both PDF (writable) and doc on your listserv

Monday, February 8

ARTSTOR DISCOVERY TASK DUE

In-class writing: What "theme" would you choose for your project #4?

  1. Gender and sexuality
  2. Nazi rise to power
  3. Politics and art
  4. Memories of the First World War

Making Sense of some Student Questions:

  • Why are the Nazis (National Socialists) so opposed to American influence? (Nation defined by "Aryan" race; could use CR; pseudo-science of genetics + anti-Semitic myths.)
  • What was the purpose of the "Entartete" show? (Barron tries to answer this question, p. 73).
  • Why are Jewish artists a particular target? Were most of the "entartete" artists Jewish? (CR Britannica, Barron)
  • What is the meaning of "entartete" as making a connection between "Art and Race" (1928) claimed by Gropius's replacement in the Bauhaus, Paul Schultze-Naumberg, who showed photographs of people he considered deformed next to portraits by modern artists (CR 58).
  • Did the Nazi leaders really believe everything they said about "degenerate" art? (And could they even draw the distinction clearly? See Barron 57, 68 for two different ways to answer this problem, and note some places where the scholar finds material for her answer: secondary sources for footnote 13, primary source for footnote 22. )
  • Is there beauty without sensuality (and what would this mean, if beauty appeals to the senses physiologically or in terms of Aristotle's pathos?) Mosse's essay tries to explore this question. Does he think there is a clear answer?

http://www.humanities.uci.edu/~rmoeller/Weimar_Images/DegenArt/nazi_art_lecture.htm

WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 9

Using the 6Cs: why do you need more than line, color, composition to analyze and discuss these images?

Ivo Saliger, The Judgment of ParisThe Judgment of Paris, by Ivo Savliger


Hannah Hoch, Cut with the Kitchen Knife Dada through the last Epoch of Weimar Beer-belly culture in Germany

THE SIX C'S OF PRIMARY SOURCE ANALYSIS  
CONTENT
Main Idea - Do this for what you get out of the image. Use analytic terms if appropriate: line, composition, color (b/w), or Alberti's ethos-logos/historia/message
CITATION
Author/Creator: what can you say about this image? http://search.eb.com/
CONTEXT
What is going on in the world, the nation, the region, or the locality when/where this image was created? Use Prof. Moeller's lectures!
CONNECTIONS
Prior Knowledge
Link this particular primary source (image or document) to other things that you already know about, or find out
COMMUNICATION
Point-of-view or bias? Is this source (image or document) reliable about the information or message or content represented here?
CONCLUSIONS
How does this particular primary source contribute to our understanding of world history or of "making" art?
 

THE HISTORY PROJECT
Nicole Gilbertson
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, IRVINE

STALIN AND SOCIALIST REALISM: An end to the early artistic experimentation of the 1920s in Russia,
new upbeat themes, attitudes, art to help us do communism better, the "right" class consciousness

http://www.humanities.uci.edu/~rmoeller/HCC_Lectures/RGM_Lecture6_rev10.html

  • Socialist Realist Art Images powerpoint (by A. Herrmann) :
https://webfiles.uci.edu/xythoswfs/webui/_xy-6050704_1-t_bsrOtvJU

 

Socialist Realism and Lady Macbeth of Mtensk:

  • What's Socialist Realism in the Soviet Union?
  • Reading for Soviet unit: Course Reader, pp. 92-96: "Soviet Literature"
  • MLA style:
    "Gorky, Maksim." Encyclopædia Britannica. 2009. Encyclopædia Britannica Online. 17  Feb.  2009  <http://search.eb.com/eb/article-9037443>.

Homework for Wednesday 2/17:

In hard copy: an "Ideas draft" of a 300-word introduction about your theme and choice of images; black-and-white printout of 4 images; draft of 300-word 6Cs caption for one image.

 

Stylistics and Grammar Prep for #4: Check the RH margin of your #3 essay for places you might need to consult EasyWriter and do exercises on the Commnet interactive site below. They are easy and they're self-correcting. Mechanics: If you need s-v agreement, look for agreement. CS is comma splice. Stylistics: Do the ones you need: if you write short, choppy sentences, do sentence-combining exercises; if your sentences need trimming, look for the word Bloated. This is on the honor system. But required: EVERYBODY must do Illogical Comparisons and Mixed Constructions, print out, and hand it to me in hard copy Wednesday. The Commnet site is:

http://grammar.ccc.commnet.edu/grammar/quiz_list.htm

Wednesday, 2/17 Culture Stalin hated, culture Stalin liked http://www.humanities.uci.edu/~rmoeller/HCC_Lectures/RGM_Lecture7_rev.html

Due: Ideas Drafts #4, Commnet exercise

Lab work: On your Messageboard: Add 100 words of visual analysis to one image on the handout (from Prof. M's new book The Nazi State and German Society): image of Nazi parents/children? image prompting response to the Battle of Stalingrad?

 

  • Shostakovich and Leskov's story: why did Shostakovich imagine Stalin would like his opera -- or any opera -- based on Leskov's 1865 story? (Think about historical fiction: rewriting the heroine's story to take place just before the Russian Revolution...) Compare and contrast: In Leskov's story, Katerina never speaks herself. Prof. M. pointed out to us that Shostakovich gave her the best musical moments, in order to show us that Shostakovich was trying to present her as the heroine, sympathetic in some ways.
  • Why didn't Stalin like it? What would Gorky say, based on his article in your CR 92-95? Was Shosty right if he felt scared by "Chaos Instead of Music"?
  • Reading: Writer's Handbook, Analyzing Music" (Chapter 18).

Lady Macbeth of Mtensk (VHS ), by Shostakovich; dir. Petr Weigl, London Philharmonic Orchestra

 

  • An American production of Lady Macbeth of Mtensk

 

 

 

Week Eight

Monday, February 22

  • Reading/Viewing: Porgy and Bess
  • Library Class: Primary and Secondary Sources in Research
  • Discovery Task #4 Assigned, "Primary vs. Secondary Sources"! will be due Wednesday

Wednesday, February 24

  • Reading/Viewing: Porgy and Bess
  • Discovery Task #4 due
  • Writing:Working Draft for Essay Four due in Dropbox Friday
  • Viewing and listening : Porgy and Bess
  • Porgy and Bess at the New York City Opera: Alvy Powell as Porgy and Marquita Lister as Bess (www.operajaponica.org)

 

Clara's famous lullaby "Summertime" (Ch. 2 of DVD): in the lyrics, where do you see Clara's hopes for her baby? Her relationship to her husband? Economic issues? Religious background? How does Grove Music describe Gershwin's melody and orchestral arrangement? How would you stage it?

Bess sings: How does Gershwin use music to develop Bess's character? If you were going to stage this work, how would you do it?

  • Use of music to develop character: Compare Bess with Katerina. Bess has lovely lyrical music to sing, but it is never her music. She has no motif. She must sing with the chorus ("Oh the train is at the station," Act I, Scene 2, Ch. 10 of DVD) together with a man (e.g., "I wants to stay here", Act II, Scene 3, DVD Ch. 22), or she sings Clara's song ("Summertime," Act III, Scene 1, DVD, Ch. 25). Prof. M. argues that this musical choice reinforces the theme of Bess as a dependent woman who is unable to shape her own identity. Do you agree? How is this staged?
  • Going off to NYC: what do you think happens to her after the story is over?

Porgy sings: How does Gershwin use music to develop Porgy's character? If you were going to stage this work, how would you do it?

  • "Bess, you is my woman now" (Ch. 14 of DVD) - Porgy
  • Which are the most important other moments for your sense of Porgy's character? How do you hear, read, understand "I got plenty of nuttin'"? What's the importance of the last line -- "Got my song"?
  • Porgy kills Crown: what's your interpretation of this? Does he become like Crown, as Prof. M. thinks?
  • What happens to Porgy in jail? Does the homecoming scene develop his character? How has he made money?

Crown and Bess: is it rape? At-home writing on Messageboard by Monday, March 1.

 

What others sing: How does Gershwin use arias, choruses, and orchestral music to develop the plot? If you were going to stage a scene involving other characters, how would you do the scene?

  • "It Ain't Necessarily So"(Ch. 17 of DVD) - Sporting Life
    Act II, Scene 4, Begins Chapter 24 of the DVD (Note: How would you stage the end of Act II, Scene 2? Does Crown rape Bess? Does she willingly go off with him into the woods? Is she raped? How does the music work for you?
  • Choral music: Call and response, the "shouting" that Gershwin heard when he visited Charleston
  • Goes into spiritual, "Oh, Doctor Jesus" -- What do we learn about the people singing this song?
  • Reprise (repeat) of Summertime - Who sings this? And to whom?
  • Music of storm segues into into spiritual, "Oh, dere's somebody knockin' at de do'..." Whom do they mean here?
  • Crown enters, recitative -- who was actually knocking at that door?
  • Red-headed woman... Crown's song -- and chorus is seduced into singing it [!]
  • Crown exits into storm -- Why does he go?

 

Week Nine: Built Environments

Monday, March 1

  • Reading: Jane Jacobs, The Death and Life of Great American Cities, 3-54 and 89-111
  • Peer Editing Comments Assigned for #4
  • Discussion: Is Porgy and Bess a celebration of African-American culture? Or racist?
  • Celebrates African-American culture? Trivializes African-American culture? Would you call it racist?
    Gershwin studied community in S.C. ? An effort you respect? But goes down to South Carolina only for a few weeks? Or: Has no right to write about the community anyway, as an outsider?
    Catfish Row inhabitants work hard ? Cotton, fish, store, etc.? But the hero is a beggar, and they do a limited range of work? (Is this racist? Or a protest against limited opportunites for Af-Ams?
    Some C.R. people are religious ? But others treat religion lightly?
    Catfish Row values families, children ? But families fail to thrive? Jake's dream of his son's going to college won't happen?
    Catfish Row members support each other But they support Porgy as murderer?
    C.R. people sing (white can't) <- inner life ! But singing stereotypes happiness?
    C.R. people outwit crooked whites But lie, and speak simplistically to them?
    Some C.R. people reject "happy dust" + alcohol But others are susceptible?
    Porgy, Bess, even Crown feel deep human emotions But unregulated passions, not healthy relationships?
    Jazz, shouts, gospel become part of opera? But presented as the only thing African-Americans can do?
    Heritage of slavery is remembered? But by "good" white man, sentimentally presented?
    Requirement that Af-Am parts be sung by African-American singers? But this is a race-based requirement?
    What would you add ? Which points are most important to you? What's your conclusion? What would you add? Which points are most important to you? What's your conclusion?
     

Wednesday, March 3

  • Reading: Teddy Cruz, "A City Made of Waste" (online in syllabus); Mike Davis, "Fortress LA" (in CR): How do Cruz and Davis think of gated communities? Compare Jacobs' idea of a neighborhood.
  • Writer's Handbook, "Analyzing Design" (Chapter 19).
  • Passage Analysis Practice: Jacobs Messageboard
    1. Paraphrase the main point of the passage.
    2. Identify two or three important keywords, explain or define
    3. Ethos of speaker, credibility
    4. Logos (logical connections, premises, metaphors /similes)
    5. Pathos -- emotions, effect on feelings of audience or reader
    6. Part to the whole - importance of passage to entire text
    7. Relate to one or more themes of winter quarter

 

 

Week Ten

C. R. Cockerell (1788-1863): The Professor's Dream: Prof. Cockerell of the Royal Academy made this huge watercolor diagram in 1848 to show his students 4000 years of architectural history. It was spread out behind his lectern as he spoke. The horizontal bands of color across the painting indicate different periods and cultures; since he painted it in 1848, architectural history stops there! But perhaps the pyramids on top point to the future that the little travelers on the bottom may someday reach. Most (not all) of the buildings are identified in the key on my office door. (Royal Academy, London).

Monday, March 8 Essay #4 Due

Thinking of Jacobs as a Primary Source: what she did, achievements; what she didn't do, limitations

 

The Kind of Problem a City is... ??? According to Jacobs , using a history of science she gets from an essay on science and complexity by Dr. Warren Weaver (1958)
A simple problem? Simplicity? A two-variable problem (17th, 18th, 19th c. physical science: foundations for our theories of light, sound, heat, electricity), p. 429?
Disorganized complexity? Many Variables but in an analyzable way, like billiard balls (post- 1900 math and physics: analytic methods for dealing with "millions of balls"), p. 430?
Organized complexity? "A sizable number of factors interrelated into an organic whole?" All varying simultaneously in interconnected but different ways (life sciences & medicine, post-1932), p. 433?

 

Jacobs: Sidewalk ballet: pp. 50 ff. Morning, heart-of-the-day, after work, deep night.

A good park has four elements of Design: intricacy, centering, sun, enclosure 103 ff.

 

  • Reading: Malcolm Gladwell, "Designs for Working" :

    MALCOLM GLADWELL ON JANE JACOBS:Most developers did not want to build the kind of community Jacobs talked about, and most Americans didn’t want to live in one.  ... Who, after all, does have a direct interest in creating diverse, vital spaces that foster creativity and serendipity? Employers do. On the 40th anniversary of its publication, Death and Life has been reborn as a primer on workplace design. (HCC Reader, p. 117)

    Gladwell builds a series of analogies between specific office types and forms of city planning.

Visualizing Your Workspace: does it look like a... Gladwell's analogy would be to a...
CORNER OFFICE? GATED COMMUNITY: would you agree?
CUBICLE? TRACT HOUSING: would you agree?

OPEN-PLAN OFFICE?

MIXED USE NEIGHBORHOOD: would you agree?

  • Writing: Essay #4 due

Wednesday, March 10: Julia Lupton: Making

Shakespeare's Globe Theatre, LondonPlace-making: how does the play acted on the stage of the Globe theater of Shakespeare's time "make" this particular urban space? Think of Jacobs' categories: a complexity that maintains both freedom and safety? How does MSND represent both free and safe places? How do the characters' actions "make" the places meaningful?

 

Three ways to consider "making" for Midsummer Night's Dream?

Craft: the skills of the "rude mechanicals"? the “made” or crafted character of Shakespeare’s drama as a collaborative art form? Drama: a form of making that involves the spoken word along with the use of movement, gesture, space, costume, lighting.

Imagination: the “made” or fictional character of the world Shakespeare represents?

Self-fashioning: the ways we all “make” our own lives, partly in response to the images and traditions, stories, scrips, rituals that surround us...?

 

 

How does Gershwin use the form of the opera (arias, choruses, and orchestral music ) to develop the plot?

  • "It Ain't Necessarily So"(Ch. 17 of DVD) - Sporting Life
    Act II, Scene 4, Begins Chapter 24 of the DVD (Note: How would you stage the end of Act II, Scene 2? Does Crown rape Bess? Does she willingly go off with him into the woods? Is she raped? How does the music work for you?
  • Choral music: Call and response, the "shouting" that Gershwin heard when he visited Charleston
  • Goes into spiritual, "Oh, Doctor Jesus" -- What do we learn about the people singing this song?
  • Reprise (repeat) of Summertime - Who sings this? And to whom?
  • Music of storm segues into into spiritual, "Oh, dere's somebody knockin' at de do'..." Whom do they mean here?
  • Crown enters, recitative -- who was actually knocking at that door?
  • Red-headed woman... Crown's song -- and chorus is seduced into singing it [!]
  • Crown exits into storm -- Why does he go?
  • Who leaves Catfish Row, and who is left at the end?
  • Is this a story about place-"making" in Catfish Row, or in New York City?

Thinking

 

  • Final exam preparation.
  1. I. Short answers: 6 out of 8 short answers. 50%
  2. II. Passage analysis: possibly Jacobs, Gorky, Hitler's speech in CR. See guidelines above.
    25%.
  3. III. Choice of two essay questions (25%). Will require use of at least one text from after the midterm.25%
  4. Could ask for a comparison essay: for ex., compare & contrast Porgy & Bess with MSND, Lady Macbeth or another text with respect to
    one of the following :
  • importance of settings
  • love, passion, desires and the possibility of controlling them
  • marriage or the lack of it
  • parent-child relations
  • tensions between communities
  • social mobility (or lack of it)
  • substances or drugs that make things happen
  • allusions to other myths or traditions or works of art
  • cultural context of time of writing play and opera
  • double-time (both play and opera are set in fictional periods before the time they were written)

CLASS POLICIES

Vivian Folkenflik
HIB 197
(in back of HCC office, which is HIB 185! Use little glass door near Artsbridge)
Office hours Wednesday 12-1, Tuesday 12-2, and by appointment

E-Mail: vrfolken@uci.edu

Phone messages: 824-6408

I teach this course because I love it and I learn from it and from you, but I do it with you, not for you. The work you do on your own, in our classroom, and with each other -- in this class and among your friends -- will be what makes the course happen for you.The Humanities Core Course is an interdisciplinary introduction to the humanities that is designed to develop your reading, writing, research, and discussion skills, challenging you to imagine, interpret, design, perform, and create. I think you will enjoy this quarter and I am looking forward to new discoveries in this new decade, with each and every one of you.

You are also expected to be responsible members of CHP and this section, as well as your campus community. Special Honors forums with Prof. Lupton and Prof. Moeller will be announced.

Attendance: Attendance in lecture and section is mandatory. More than two absences will affect your grade. More than three absences will be grounds for failure in the course. Excused absences will require medical documentation. Late arrivals can be counted as absences. To receive full credit for attendance, you will also be expected to participate with appropriate comments, questions, and attentiveness.

The writing grade is determined by performance on two essays and participation in required research and writing exercises. Although the writing participation requirement numerically accounts for 10% of your writing grade, failure to participate is grounds for failure in this portion of the course. The writing participation grade will be determined by research assignments ("Discovery Tasks"), participation in peer editing and the drafting process, your responses to reading and discussion questions, and in-class writing activities and quizzes.

The lecture grade is determined by performance on the midterm examination (40%) and final examination (50%), and participation in class discussion, performance if you so choose. Although the lecture participation requirement numerically accounts for 10% of your lecture grade, failure to participate is grounds for failure in the course. The lecture participation grade will be determined by responses to weekly reading and discussion questions, lab work, any required argument and interpretation exercises, postings to the listserv, and in-class discussion and debateGroupwork is a participatory experience with other classmates and may involve writing.   Lecture attendance is a mandatory element in discussion participation; quizzes may also be used to estimate this attendance.

Note: No late papers are accepted in this section without a written medical excuse or other documented major emergency. I am happy to help you get an early start on your written assignments. You are responsible for backing up texts composed on a computer, and failures of software or hardware are not acceptable reasons for a late assignment. All drafts, assignments, and final essays written outside of class must be typed and in proper format. Final drafts are to be submitted in a folder that includes pre-writing, previous drafts, notes from any conferences with me, and peer editing comments. Save all work.

Standard Written English: In keeping with the Standard Written English policy of this course, you will be expected to correct errors in mechanics, usage, grammar, and spelling. Consider using the Commnet self-correcting interactive quiz page for mechanics: grammar.ccc.commnet.edu/grammar/quiz_list.htm

Plagiarism: Academic work requires you to acknowledge all your sources responsibly. Plagiarism is a serious matter and will be handled by the appropriate authorities. Supervisors and instructors in this course regularly review suspect papers. Turning in any work which is not your own and not properly acknowledged as such will result in a recommendation for failure in the course and subject you to further action by the university. Please review the university policy on academic dishonesty and speak to me if you have questions.

Internet: Internet sources must also be properly acknowledged. For more information about how to cite Internet sources, review the Internet use policies for HCC in the Guide. This quarter you should be familiar with the "References" section of the main web page (http://e3.uci.edu/programs/humcore) In addition, as part of a program-wide effort to discourage plagiarism, you are asked to submit your essay to http://www.TurnItIn.com (as a pasted file).

E-mail queries to me at vrfolken@uci.edu should assume delays in transmission and the observance of normal university business days by instructors and staff in the course. Always allow time for delays. Telephone Messages if necessary: 824-6408; x4-6408

FINAL EXAM HH 142. Note your exam time carefully!

Friday, March 19 1:30-3:30 in our classroom. Bring two clean bluebooks (just in case you need the second one).

RESOURCES: LINKS

OXFORD ENGLISH DICTIONARY
http://dictionary.oed.com/

Encyclopedia Britannica Online http://search.eb.com/

Library of Congress site: http://www.loc.gov/

Reference sites on Prof. Moeller's Bag of Tricks

Grammar and Style Quizzes
grammar.ccc.commnet.edu/grammar/quiz_list.htm

HCC glossary
argument, valid, true, premise, conclusion, probable, conclusive, ethos, logos, pathos, rhetoric, interpretation, thesis, topic sentence, transition, fallacy,
analysis, synthesis, claim, evidence, warrant, explication, application

 

 

 

 

 

C. R. Cockerell (1788-1863): The Professor's Dream: Prof. Cockerell of the Royal Academy painted this watercolor diagram to show his students 4000 years of architectural history. The horizontal bands of color across the painting indicate different periods and cultures; since he painted it in 1848, architectural history stops there! But perhaps the pyramids on top point to the future that the little travelers on the bottom may someday reach. Most (not all) of the buildings are identified in the key on my office door. (Royal Academy, London).

 

 

 

  • The Artist in the Character of Design, listening to the inspiration of Poetry, by Angelica Kauffmann (1782), Kenwood Iveagh Bequest London (Yorck Project)

    The Artist in the Character of Design, listening to the inspiration of Poetry, by Angelica Kauffmann (1782), Kenwood Iveagh Bequest, London (Yorck Project)

    Angelica Kauffman's "The Artist in the Character of Design, Listening to the Inspiration of Poetry" (1782, Kenwood House, London) This istoria includes a self-portrait by a woman artist. At the time it was painted, shortly before the French Revolution (halfway between Alberti and the Bauhaus?), women were finding their voice as artists and writers in what scholars now call "the public sphere." The representation of Poetry as an inspirational female Muse holding her lyre is traditional, and so is the neo-classical architecture, but the gaze of the artist seems to invite the viewer into the interaction of her moment of creation. She is real (Design's modern shoe touches the ground) but she is interacting with the timeless (Poetry's foot is raised on the dais, and is clad only in a classical sandal). Some people have seen the artist as hesitant, but her gesture in picking up her pencil seems to be one of getting ready for work. Perhaps she is intending to draw us, the viewers. As Alberti would suggest, she intends to draw first, and add color later. What is the inspiration of Poetry telling her about us? This istoria not only depicts the process of painting (line-composition-color) but asks us this question about ourselves in this single moment. Its immediacy and intimacy are part of the power of the painting.

    Where would I go with this caption? What other interpretive or scholarly questions can I ask about it, and where would I go to answer them? Visual analysis questions: Ethos in the drawing or line, a message I appreciate in the composition/istoria, pathos in the personal associations I have with it and in the pleasure I take from its color. Point-of-view questions: What might Alberti think of it? What might Hannah Höch think of it? What-if historical questions: What might Heartfield and Grosz say if it had been the painting Kokoschka was referring to (instead of Rubens' Bathsheba)? Does asking these questions make me love the painting less, or find ways to love it more? Finding out the facts: When I looked in Grove for the artist's name, I found that the spelling Angelica/Angelika Kauffmann Kaufman was uncertain: is this because of her nationality? Gender questions: What do we learn about women artists professionally in this time period? Could Kauffmann be a member of the Royal Academy in London? Was she accepted as a painter of istorias? What do the words in the upper left hand corner say, and who wrote them? For me, this would be a great research topic because I love the painting so much that I wouldn't mind spending time finding out more, and more, and more about its creator... What are your key interests? What would you like to spend some time finding out?

 

RESOURCES: LINKS

OXFORD ENGLISH DICTIONARY
http://dictionary.oed.com/

Encyclopedia Britannica Online http://search.eb.com/

Library of Congress site: http://www.loc.gov/

Grammar and Style Quizzes
Interactive quizzes and games online

grammar.ccc.commnet.edu/grammar/quiz_list.htm

HCC glossary
argument, valid, true, premise, conclusion, probable, conclusive, ethos, logos, pathos, rhetoric, interpretation, thesis, topic sentence, transition, fallacy,
analysis, synthesis, claim, evidence, warrant, explication, application

 

CLASS POLICIES

Vivian Folkenflik
HIB 197
(in back of HCC office, which is HIB 185! Use door near Artsbridge)
Office hours Tuesday and Thursday 12-1:00, Monday 1:30-2:30 and by appointment
E-Mail
: vrfolken@uci.edu

I teach this course because I love it and I learn from it and from you, but I do it with you, not for you. The work you do on your own, in our classroom, and with your fellow students will be what makes the course happen for you.The Humanities Core Course is an interdisciplinary introduction to the humanities that is designed to develop your reading, writing, research, and discussion skills, challenging your skills in argumentation, interpretation, and design. You are also expected to become responsible members of a small intellectual community, this Core section, as well as your campus community.

Attendance: Attendance in lecture and section is mandatory. More than two absences will affect your grade. More than three absences will be grounds for failure in the course. Excused absences will require medical documentation. Late arrivals can be counted as absences. To receive full credit for attendance, you will also be expected to participate with appropriate comments, questions, and attentiveness.

The writing grade is determined by performance on three essays (30%, 30%, and 30%) and participation in required research and writing exercises. Although the writing participation requirement numerically accounts for 10% of your writing grade, failure to participate is grounds for failure in this portion of the course. The writing participation grade will be determined by research assignments("Discovery Tasks"), participation in peer editing and the drafting process, your final portfolio of writing, which will include your responses to reading and discussion questions, and in-class writing activities and quizzes.

The lecture grade is determined by performance on the midterm examination (40%) and final examination (50%), and participation (25%) . Although the lecture participation requirement numerically accounts for 10% of your lecture grade, failure to participate is grounds for failure in the course. The lecture participation grade will be determined by responses to weekly reading and discussion questions, lab work, any required argument and interpretation exercises, postings to the listserv, and in-class discussion and debateGroupwork is a participatory experience with other classmates and may involve writing.   Lecture attendance is a mandatory element in discussion participation, and quizzes may also be used to estimate this attendance, without which you cannot participate fully .

Note: No late papers are accepted in this section without a written medical excuse or other documented major emergency. I am happy to help you get an early start on your written assignments. You are responsible for backing up texts composed on a computer, and failures of software or hardware are not acceptable reasons for a late assignment. All drafts, assignments, and final essays written outside of class must be typed and in proper format. Final drafts are to be submitted in a folder that includes pre-writing, previous drafts, notes from any conferences with me, and peer editing comments. Save all work.

Standard Written English: In keeping with the Standard Written English policy of this course, you will be expected to correct errors in mechanics, usage, grammar, and spelling. Consider using the Commnet self-correcting interactive quiz page for mechanics: grammar.ccc.commnet.edu/grammar/quiz_list.htm

Plagiarism: Academic work requires you to acknowledge all your sources responsibly. Plagiarism is a serious matter and will be handled by the appropriate authorities. Supervisors and instructors in this course regularly review suspect papers. Turning in any work which is not your own and not properly acknowledged as such will result in a recommendation for failure in the course and subject you to further action by the university. Please review the university policy on academic dishonesty and speak to me if you have questions.

Internet: Internet sources must also be properly acknowledged. For more information about how to cite Internet sources, review the Internet use policies for HCC in the Guide. This quarter you should be familiar with the "References" section of the main web page (http://e3.uci.edu/programs/humcore) In addition, as part of a program-wide effort to discourage plagiarism, you are asked to submit your essay to http://www.TurnItIn.com (as a pasted file).

E-mail queries to me at vrfolken@uci.edu should assume delays in transmission and the observance of normal university business days by instructors and staff in the course. Always allow time for delays. Telephone Messages if necessary: 824-6408; x4-6408